Extreme: The part about the holy-mouth-man jabbing an awl into an exposed nerve made me cringe. That is definitely something that we wouldn't do here...well, unless you're at the dentist. It doesn't mean its completely barbaric. It just isn't up to what we do. Also, the thing about women baking their heads in an oven is a little strange.
Similar: The daily body ritual of the mouth-rite sounds a lot like some kind of weird teeth brushing to me. I think that we probably do some things similar, but just in different ways. They don't have crest and oral-b selling toothbrushes and toothpaste in their area. So maybe this is some kind of alternative? Going back to the thing about women baking their heads in an oven for an hour...it's like a day at the salon...kind of.
Primitive: Their healing rituals seem to be very primitive. Like I said in the last paragraph, they don't have the same luxuries that we have so it's like they're just working with what they have and what they know. They don't have a yale trained physician with an ample supply of medical necessities. They're working with what they've got and what has "worked" (or worked well enough) for hundreds of years for them.
Modest: The article mentions how these people do a lot of things in private and seem to be ashamed of some. Being pregnant, naked or anything having to do with the "restroom" they do in secret on their own. A lot of the time when you think of another culture that is not very "westernized" you think of them running around as savage animals just doing everything out in the open. These people seem to be the opposite of that.
Religious: The article states that each family has at least one shrine. I would think that this indicates that most have more than one and they make this a big part of their daily life. A lot of other religions do this same thing. It is interesting how that carries over to different cultures no matter what it is that you worship.
Part B
1.) As an American, I feel fine with my choice of descriptive words. I don't feel like they were too judgmental or rash.
2.) Yes, I believe that they do. I said that they were primitive. Which they are- in our society. In their world and society they are probably right up to par. I also said they were extreme for some of their rituals and customs. Compared to us, they are.
3.) For primitive I cant think of a single word I would use. But probably just "set in ways. For extreme I guess I would just say "different".
4) It would be best to approach these situations with a free and clear mind. I am in the process of studying and converting to buddhism and this assignment helped me realize that I am not bringing that aspect into all parts of my life. I should have approached this assignment at first with a 100% black mind and free slate so that I could not compare them to my own society and way of life but focus on the beauty and individuality of their ways.
You said: "Compared to us, they are."
ReplyDeleteBut they ARE us! Your words are describing our own culture. Nacerima = American. So do you consider us to be primitive?
Regardless, primitive is a bias word that anthropologists now avoid like the plague. It doesn't provide much information except as a comparative one to the anthropologist's own. But what if their report is read by an anthropologist from a different culture? Is the comparison still accurate? It is possible that it is not. So words that actually describe instead of just judge are preferred.
Good analysis and good post.
Harrah's Casino Hotel Tunica - KTNV
ReplyDeleteHarrah's Tunica Casino 밀양 출장샵 Hotel 서귀포 출장마사지 Tunica. 1 Tunica Way, 서울특별 출장마사지 Tunica 광주 출장샵 Resorts, MS 39530. 공주 출장샵 (662) 226-7000 Website. http://www.casinos.us/harrahs-casino